Categories
Mining Business

A title search either clears or it doesn’t. How a title commitment, Schedule B exceptions, and an Owner’s Policy actually work before you close.

The facility had been running for fourteen months when the letter arrived. A pipeline company holding a decades-old, recorded easement across the back third of the parcel had noticed, from a satellite image, that a transformer pad now sat inside its right-of-way buffer. The easement had been there the entire time, recorded in the county clerk’s office since before the current owner’s grandfather bought the land. Nobody had missed it out of carelessness. The purchase had closed with a quitclaim deed and no title examination at all, because the price was good and everyone involved assumed a rural parcel with one owner for sixty years did not need one.

A title problem does not usually look like fraud or a forged deed. It looks like exactly this: a real, properly recorded instrument that nobody surfaced before signing, because surfacing it is a specific, procedural step and not something that happens automatically just because a sale closes.

What a Title Search Is Actually Checking

A title search is an examination of the public land records — deeds, mortgages, liens, easements, judgments, and other recorded instruments — to confirm who actually owns a parcel and what, besides the owner, has a claim against it. It is not a formality layered on top of a real estate closing; historically, it exists because the recording system only tells you what is on file, not whether what is on file is complete, accurate, or correctly interpreted, and errors in that chain used to fall entirely on the buyer. A Pennsylvania case from 1868, Watson v. Muirhead, is the usually-cited origin point: a conveyancer missed a prior lien, the buyer lost the resulting dispute, and the court held the conveyancer wasn’t liable for a non-negligent search error — which is the gap title insurance was created to close. Pennsylvania authorized title insurance companies in 1874, and the industry has operated on essentially the same logic since: the search finds what is of record, and the policy covers what the search misses or gets wrong.

A title search comes back one of two ways. Either it turns up nothing beyond the routine, clearable items every parcel carries, or it turns up something that has to be resolved, insured over, or renegotiated before closing — an unreleased lien, a missing signature, a boundary discrepancy, an heir who never signed off on a prior transfer. For a residential buyer that second outcome is usually an inconvenience the closing agent clears in a week. For an industrial site carrying heavy equipment, a power interconnection, and a hosting contract built around a specific footprint, the same category of defect can mean the thing you actually paid for — unencumbered use of a specific pad location — was never fully available.

The Title Commitment: What It Promises and What It Excludes

Before closing, a title insurer issues a title commitment, which states what it will insure once the transaction closes and on what conditions. It is typically organized into two parts. Schedule A identifies the property, the proposed insured, and the type and amount of coverage. Schedule B lists the exceptions — the things the policy will not cover unless they are specifically cleared or insured over before closing.

Schedule B exceptions on raw or rural industrial land commonly include:

  • Easements — recorded rights-of-way for utilities, pipelines, drainage, or access that run across the parcel and limit what can be built where, even though the owner still holds title to the ground underneath.
  • Mineral reservations — a prior owner who sold the surface but kept the minerals, or vice versa. This is the same split-estate concept covered in our guide to gas royalties and mineral rights, but from the opposite direction: that guide assumes you already know the split exists and explains the economics of dealing with it; a title exception is how you find out it exists in the first place, on a parcel where nobody mentioned it during negotiation.
  • Liens and judgments — recorded claims against the seller or a prior owner that attach to the property rather than to the person, including tax liens and unresolved mechanics liens from work the current owner may not even have ordered.
  • Survey matters and encroachments — boundary lines that do not match the recorded legal description, fences or structures that cross a property line, or a gap between two adjoining legal descriptions that leaves a sliver of ground belonging to neither.
  • Standard exceptions — a boilerplate set every policy carries unless specifically removed, typically covering unrecorded easements apparent on inspection, rights of parties in possession, and matters a current survey would disclose. These are commonly deleted or modified once an actual survey and a physical inspection are provided to the title company.

Owner’s Policy vs. Lender’s Policy, and Why the Difference Matters Here

Title insurance comes in two forms that protect different parties and do not substitute for each other. An Owner’s Policy protects the buyer’s equity in the property and insures that title is vested in the purchaser, free of the defects and encumbrances the policy covers; coverage runs for as long as the owner holds an interest, at no recurring cost. A Lender’s Policy, by contrast, is issued only to the mortgage lender, protects only the lender’s ability to foreclose and recover its loan, follows the loan if it is sold on the secondary market, and provides no protection to the owner at all.

An all-cash industrial land purchase, common in this business, has no lender requiring a policy — which means that unless the buyer specifically requests and pays for an Owner’s Policy, nobody independently verifies the title at all beyond whatever examination the closing attorney happens to do. Skipping the Owner’s Policy to save a closing cost line item is the single most common way an operator ends up fully exposed to exactly the kind of defect this guide describes, discovered well after the equipment is installed and moving is no longer a realistic option.

The Comparison That Matters: What Each Approach Actually Buys

ApproachWhat it catchesWhat it leaves you exposed to
No title work, quitclaim deed onlyNothing — confirms the seller is transferring whatever interest they have, not that the interest is cleanEverything: prior liens, easements, mineral splits, boundary defects, forged or defective prior deeds
Title search, no insuranceWhatever the examiner finds in the records as of the search dateExaminer error, instruments outside the searched chain, and any future claim — there is no policy to make a claim against
Title commitment + Owner’s Policy, standard exceptions onlyRecorded defects outside Schedule B, examiner error, many off-record risks depending on policy formWhatever is specifically listed as an exception and never cleared or insured over before closing
Title commitment + Owner’s Policy, with a current survey and a UCC/judgment lien search addedThe above, plus boundary and encroachment issues a survey reveals, plus unreleased personal-property liens that could attach to fixturesCosts more and takes longer, but is the version that actually matches what an industrial site with fixed equipment and a recorded mortgage-like hosting structure needs

The honest trade-off is cost and time against the size of the asset at risk. A full examination with a current survey and a lien search adds real closing cost and typically a few weeks to the timeline. For a parcel that will carry a multi-megawatt facility, a power interconnection, and years of operating history, that cost is small against the alternative of discovering a defect after the containers are already on the pad.

A Hypothetical Walk-Through, With Round Numbers

The figures below are a round hypothetical used to illustrate the trade-off, not a quoted price for any real transaction — actual title premiums and survey costs are set by the title company, the state, and the parcel’s own complexity. Say a 40-acre industrial parcel is selling for a price in the low seven figures, all cash, no lender involved. A full title commitment, a current ALTA/NSPS survey to clear the standard survey exception, a UCC and judgment-lien search, and an Owner’s Policy sized to the purchase price might add a closing cost on the order of one to two percent of the purchase price and a few additional weeks before closing, mostly waiting on the survey crew and the examiner.

Skipping all of that saves those weeks and that line item. It also means that if the fourteen-month-later letter in the opening example arrives, there is no policy to make a claim against, no examiner’s error to point to, and no insured amount to draw on — the operator is litigating a property dispute directly, at whatever cost that turns out to be, with a transformer pad already poured in the wrong place. The arithmetic that matters is not the size of the closing-cost line item. It is the ratio between that line item and the cost of moving or re-engineering a fixed, multi-megawatt installation after the fact, which is not a close comparison in either direction.

Before You Sign the Purchase Agreement

  • Request the title commitment and read Schedule B yourself, in full, rather than relying on a summary — ask the title company or attorney to explain every exception in plain language, including ones that look boilerplate.
  • Order a current ALTA/NSPS survey and provide it to the title company before closing specifically to clear or narrow the standard survey exception; an old or sketch-level survey from a prior transaction is not the same thing.
  • Run a UCC financing-statement search against both the real property and the seller’s name, separate from the real estate title search — a UCC filing attaches to personal property and fixtures and will not necessarily show up in a standard title examination.
  • Buy the Owner’s Policy even on an all-cash deal with no lender requiring one. The absence of a lender is exactly the condition under which nobody else is independently checking this for you.
  • Where a mineral reservation shows up as an exception, do not treat it as the same question as the royalty economics covered elsewhere — first confirm what was actually reserved and by whom, because a severed mineral estate can carry its own right to use the surface that affects where you can safely build.
  • If anything in Schedule B is unclear or contested, get it resolved, cleared, or specifically insured over in writing before closing. “The title company didn’t flag it as a problem” and “the title company specifically agreed to insure over it” are different levels of protection, and only the second one is enforceable later.

Where This Sits Relative to the Rest of the Deal

This is upstream of construction-phase risk, not a substitute for it. Mechanics liens are claims that can attach to the property after you own it, from work done during the build; a title defect is something that was already true about the property before you ever signed, waiting to be found. The two protections run on different tracks and a buyer needs both: a clean title at closing, and lien protection through construction. Confirming you can finance, operate, and eventually sell a specific footprint cleanly belongs on the same pre-closing checklist as the site-selection diligence already covered on this site — it is simply the step that confirms you actually have clean legal rights to the ground you spent all that other diligence evaluating.

None of this requires specialized expertise to start. Ordering a title commitment and a current survey is a routine request any real estate attorney or title company handles daily; the cost is modest against the size of an industrial land purchase. The expensive version of this problem is not the title search. It is the lien, easement, or mineral reservation you find out about fourteen months after the containers are running. If you are evaluating a parcel now, get in touch before the purchase agreement is signed, or consider hosted capacity where the title question on the underlying ground has already been settled.

Explore Rax Mining

Categories